PORCUPINE TREE - Steve Wilson - "Eclectic Earwig Reviews Music and More for You!"    
HOME PAGE, prog rock, jazz fusion, jazz rock, jazz, pysch/trance, space, electronic, ambient, essentially eclectic excellence
EER-MUSIC.com HOME PAGE

GO HOME
EER-MUSIC.com
MEET THE STAFF HERE



Porcupine Tree: Stupid Dream (CD, 59:55) Kscope Records 128132 1999
Kscope Records
P.O. Box 1288
Gerrards Cross, Bucks
SL9 9YB
ENGLAND

If Signify was the CD that bridged Porcupine Tree's psychedelic past
to its more pop-friendly future, then Stupid Dream is the album that
solidifies the band's intentions of moving away from ambient soundscapes and
becoming more of a mainstream song-oriented act.  Gone are the trippy
10-minute acid-induced sonic journeys that were the trademark of bandleader
Steve Wilson, they're now replaced with "proper" songs complete with
standard verses and catchy choruses.  While this shift will probably
disappoint some of PT's long-time fans, it's really not fair to dismiss
Stupid Dream solely based on the assumption that "Wilson's gone pop".
Most of the tunes on the CD are indeed more conventional, but rest assured
that PT's songs still have hooks planted firmly in Pink Floyd-like
space-rock. The difference is now the compositions are more structured and
less free form. If you're willing to take a journey to new territory with PT
and Steve Wilson on Stupid Dream, your open-mindedness will be
rewarded with some very well-crafted prog/pop.

Stupid Dream kicks off with a song that sounds like it could have
been ripped-off from David Gilmour's hidden vaults titled "Even Less." The
song features some excellent guitar riffs from Wilson, and contains
fantastic use of a live string section resulting in an absolutely dreamy
(and catchy) chorus.  Similar tracks that capture that Floyd-ish vibe
include "Don't Hate Me" - which contains some great sax work from Theo
Travis - and the jazzy closer "Stop Swimming" with its beautiful piano
accompaniment and meandering drum patterns. Counterbalancing these more
spacey tracks is the straight-ahead pop of "This is No Rehearsal" and "Slave
Called Shiver," a couple of well-composed but ultimately forgettable
mainstream tunes. There's nothing particularly bad about these tunes, it's
just that Steve Wilson is capable of so much more than quaint pop songs. To
his credit, Wilson does manage to fire off an excellent pop tune with the
track "Piano Lessons," a track that is basically a piece of early 60's Brit
pop augmented with one of Wilson's ethereal choruses.

There really are only a couple of complete miscues on Stupid Dream.
One is the song "Pure Narcotic" that is so derivative of Radiohead that I'm
surprised that Wilson hasn't received a subpoena from Thom Yorke yet.  The
other clunker is the 6 minute instrumental "Tinto Brass," a quirky band
composition that really seems to go nowhere at all.  However, other than
those two tracks, Stupid Dream is an album filled with very nice
prog/pop songs that should be attractive to fans of Pink Floyd and the like.
I'm not sure why Steve Wilson has decided to steer PT away from psychedelia
towards more mainstream music, but on Stupid Dream he does prove to
be more than capable at making the switch.

- Michael Askounes (michael@gscyclone.com)

CREDITS:
Richard Barbieri: Analogue Synths, Hammond Organ, Mellotron
Colin Edwin: Bass
Chris Maitland: Drums, Percussion
Steven Wilson: Vocals, Guitars, Piano, Samples
Theo Travis: Flutes, Saxes
East of England Orchestra: Strings

TRACKLIST:
1. Even Less (7:11)
2. Piano Lessons (4:21)
3. Stupid Dream (0:28)
4. Pure Narcotic (5:02)
5. Slave Called Shiver (4:41)
6. Don't Hate Me (8:30)
7. This is No Rehearsal (3:27)
8. Baby Dream in Cellophane (3:15)
9. Stranger by the Minute (4:31)
10. A Smart Kid (5:22)
11. Tinto Brass (6:17)
12. Stop Swimming (6:53)

More information on Porcupine Tree can be found at
http://www.porcupinetree.com

GO TO PREVIOUS PAGE

GO BACK


RETURN TO:


To purchase this recording and get more info, soundclips, etc.

CLICK ON ARTIST'S NAME ABOVE

OR . . .

Please visit my BUY IT E.E.R. NOW INDEX PAGE
OR...
Please try my brand spankin' new

EER and AMAZON.com QUIK-LINKs
buyer's guide to recommended music.


OR ...
go to my LINKS page and find the vendors' section.
Happy hunting!


ALL YOUR CDS ARE BELONG TO US.
Observe how the word
wheel reverses direction
if you try and read words.
EER-MUSIC.com HOME PAGE