"Eclectic Earwig Reviews Music and More for You!"
HOME PAGE, prog rock, jazz fusion, jazz rock, jazz, pysch/trance, space, electronic, ambient, essentially eclectic excellence
EER-MUSIC.com HOME PAGE

GO HOME
EER-MUSIC.com
MEET THE STAFF HERE




Dali's Dilemma: Manifesto For Futurism
Magna Carta Records MA-9024-2, 1999.
Produced by Matt Guillory, Pat Reyes and Mike Varney.
http://www.magnacarta.net/

          It's very hard for any recording artist to deliver a first musical
statement that isn't derivative of its influences; witness Beethoven,
whose first symphony was pure Haydn. So it should surprise no one that
the point of reference on the debut by Dali's Dilemma is Dream Theater circa
"Awake". Prog-metal, metallic-prog, or whatever you chose to call it, has
become the dominant trend in prog during the 90s, with Dream Theater the
movement's standard bearer, providing a solid blue-print for musicians
wishing to operate in the prog-metal arena, in the same way that Genesis set
the agenda for many symphonic, and later neo-symphonic, rock bands.

          Dali's Dilemma are adept disciples of the Dream Theater school,
possessing the technical chops needed to deliver the hybrid of shifting time
signatures, hard-hitting quasi-metallic riffing, lush keyboard fills, furious
double-bass pedal driven drumming, all topped with the Deep Purple derived
slightly desperate vocals.

          Dali's Dilemma places more emphasis on melody then their mentors,
especially during the vocal passages, managing to write several songs that
are eminently hummable. They also have the same knack for interesting
guitar and keyboard lines that harmonize and mimic each other, or dance
adroitly around each other.

          At its best the band rocks hard, creating metallic textured songs
that showcase a great deal of ability and versatility. They manage to
avoid the most glaring of grunting prog-metal cliches, and even create some
tasteful U2ish moments, most noticeably "Can't You See".

          Two short instrumentals, one a guitar and one a synthesizer
showcase, are used to break up the prog-metal onslaught. This is probably just
as well since the biggest weakness is that many of the tunes sound the
same. Part of that is the production approach, and part of it is the choice
of instrumentation and tones used (particularly electric guitar and the
ubiquitous string synths). There were times when I had to refer to the track
listing because of the sonic similarity of the tunes.

          If you're not already a fan of the Dream Theater school of
progressive-metal, pulverized by maniacally pummeling double-bass pedals,
this isn't the place to start. But if you're into the genre, this could
be a good addition to your library. Hopefully Dali's Dilemma will have
a better handle on its sound with the next record; right now they're too
much like their mentors to have an identity of their own, which may cause
many fans of non-metallic prog to bypass them.

          Who might like this? Dream Theater fans in need of a between DT
albums fix. Anyone wanting good background music for a game of
"Panzergruppe Guderian". 

          Who might dislike this? Anyone who's not a prog-metal fan, or not
a fan of tortured metal vocal heroes in general.

The best songs:
"Miracles In Yesterday"
"Ashen Days"
"Can't You See"
"Living In Fear"*

*(The track that best represents the bands style: "Living In Fear".)

Star rating: 2  out of 5; 3 out of 5 if Im in a metal mood. Ill keep it,
but it might wind up in my trade pile.

  ~ Steven Davies-Morris
Personnel: Matthew Bradley -- vocals Pat Reyes -- guitars Jeremy Colson -- drums Steve Reyes -- bass Matt Guillory -- keyboards. Songs: 01. Within A Stare [5:48] 02. Miracles In Yesterday [7:09] 03. Despite The Waves [5:49] 04. Whispers (instrumental) [2:04] 05. Ashen Days [5:27] 06. Andromeda Sunrise (instrumental) [2:00] 07. This Time Around [4:50] 08. Hills Of Memory [4:47] 09. Can't You See [5:15] 10. Living In Fear [7:41]

GO TO PREVIOUS PAGE

GO BACK


RETURN TO:


To purchase this recording and get more info, soundclips, etc.

CLICK ON ARTIST'S NAME ABOVE

OR . . .

Please visit my BUY IT E.E.R. NOW INDEX PAGE
OR...
Please try my brand spankin' new

EER and AMAZON.com QUIK-LINKs
buyer's guide to recommended music.


OR ...
go to my LINKS page and find the vendors' section.
Happy hunting!


ALL YOUR CDS ARE BELONG TO US.
Observe how the word
wheel reverses direction
if you try and read words.
EER-MUSIC.com HOME PAGE